Writing Critiques
September 29th, 2006A few suggestions for critiquing a web site, kiosk, DVD or game…
Pre-Writing
1 Find a major web site, kiosk or DVD, or game that you find interesting.
2. Study and analyze the writing, the structure, and presentation.
3. Think about how well the content keeps your interest and helps you to access information.
4. Take notes on first impressions.
Writing
You might include:
• An introduction that describes the content, purpose, intended audience, and scope
• An analysis of the information architecture
• Comments on what works well
• Suggestions on what could be improved
• Any feature that doesn’t fit the program
• A concluding paragraph that summarizes your feelings about the multimedia work.
Overall Objectives
Identify, Summarize and Evaluate
• Make a few key points about the work
• Analyze it. Take it apart.
• What are the major components?
• How do you like the design?
• How do the parts work together?
• Does the design fulfill its basic purpose?
• Is the audience well defined?
Objectives for the Leading Paragraph
Strong Reactions and Overview
• Write an introduction that describes, in general, the work
• What are your initial reactions?
• What do you think of the work as a whole.
• What are the issues?
Objectives for Concluding Paragraph
Provide an Overall Critical Evaluation
• Does the work achieve its purpose?
• What is the most important final comment you want to make?
• Could the design or structure have been better? How so?
